BC Journal

Inbound Acquisition Trap

The Inbound Acquisition Trap: Why Unsolicited Offers Rarely Favor Business Owners

Peter Clarke, CM&AA
Peter Clarke, CM&AA
Sergio Alvares
Sergio Alvares, CVA®, MBA

Publication Date: July 29, 2026

Receiving an unsolicited inquiry from a potential business buyer can feel validating. After years of building a firm, someone is expressing interest in buying what you have created.

But owners should be careful not to fall into what many M&A advisors call the “flattery trap”, which is the assumption that inbound interest automatically means full market value or the right deal structure.

Professional buyers acquire companies for a living. Most owners sell a business once. That imbalance shapes the conversation from the very beginning to the buyer’s advantage.

An inbound approach may represent a real opportunity. However, before moving too quickly, owners should step back and consider three questions:

  1. How do I avoid losing leverage early?
  2. Is this the right deal and buyer?
  3. Am I prepared for a transaction process?

Owners should also carefully contemplate the risk/reward dynamics that exist when considering engaging in a “one-off” opportunity. On one hand, entertaining an unsolicited offer may appear to provide the quickest path to an exit, but an owner should truly evaluate the merits between speed and immediacy against thoroughness and control.

There is a tradeoff here and it should be assessed in the context of the probability of success. Said another way, closing a business sale is quite frankly hard and time consuming. You are putting all of your proverbial eggs in a single basket by engaging with only one partner. While these opportunities can result in favorable outcomes, many factors must be aligned and the risks understood before selecting this path.

Equally important, it is critical to understand that this is a two-way process: owners should conduct reverse diligence on prospective buyers to understand their background, motivations, ability to add value and level of commitment/preparedness. It may seem counterintuitive, but serious buyers often welcome the seller bringing experienced advisors into the conversation early.

#Finterms: Earnout

What is it?
An earnout is a transaction structure in which a portion of a business's purchase price is paid after closing, contingent upon the company achieving specific future performance targets.

Earnout metrics may be based on revenue, EBITDA, gross profit, customer retention, or other agreed-upon operational and financial milestones over a defined period. If the targets are achieved, the seller receives additional consideration. If they are not achieved, some or all of the earnout payment may be forfeited.

Why it Matters?
Earnouts are commonly used when buyers and sellers have different views regarding a business's future performance. They can help bridge valuation gaps while sharing risk between both parties. However, earnouts can also introduce complexity, as future payments often depend on how the business is managed after closing.

Key Insight:
An earnout increases the headline value of a transaction only if the performance targets are realistic, measurable, and achievable. When evaluating an offer, business owners should carefully assess the likelihood of receiving the earnout proceeds rather than focusing exclusively on the total stated purchase price.

#Earnout #BusinessSale #DealStructure #PrivateEquity #MergersAndAcquisitions #ExitPlanning

Portions of this material were developed with the assistance of Artificial Intelligence (AI) tools. All information has been reviewed and verified by BaldwinClarke staff for accuracy and appropriateness prior to distribution.

#Finterms: Letter of Intent (LOI)

What is it?
A Letter of Intent (LOI) is a preliminary document that outlines the key terms and conditions of a proposed business acquisition before definitive legal agreements are prepared.

While most provisions of a Letter of Intent are non-binding, an LOI typically addresses important transaction components such as purchase price, deal structure, exclusivity, timing, due diligence expectations, and other major economic and operational terms.

Why it Matters?
The LOI serves as the framework for the remainder of the transaction process. Although it is not usually the final agreement, many of the deal's most important economic and structural terms are negotiated at this stage. Sellers who focus solely on purchase price may overlook provisions that ultimately affect transaction certainty, after-tax proceeds, and post-closing obligations.

Key Insight:
A favorable Letter of Intent is not necessarily the one with the highest headline valuation. The strongest LOIs balance economics, risk allocation, deal certainty, and alignment between buyer and seller objectives.

#LetterofIntent #LOI #BusinessSale #MergersAndAcquisitions #ExitPlanning

Portions of this material were developed with the assistance of Artificial Intelligence (AI) tools. All information has been reviewed and verified by BaldwinClarke staff for accuracy and appropriateness prior to distribution.